Why ADHD Supplements Didn't Work

Supplements is one of my favorite subjects because I prescribe supplements for my patients all the time.

If you go to any regular dietitians or nutritionist, they’ll freak out if you tell them that you take any kind of supplements.

You’ll be lectured on how supplements are not regulated, “you’re wasting money” because none of the claims are proven or approved, and so on, and on…

I, on the other hand, loves them because, when you use the right supplements properly the way it’s supposed to, they’re magical.

But patients come to me all the time with all kinds of supplements they buy from GNC, Vitamin Shoppe, Whole Foods and anywhere online.

99% of the time they don’t know what’s in it. All they know is that the sales clerk says “it’ll help with your [insert problem]”.

Is the sales clerk a medical doctor or registered dietitian just so happen to work part-time at the store?

It bothers me that people would pay hundreds of dollars on useless supplements recommended by a sales clerk, who makes minimum wage to pay his or her rent.

Then, they’ll complain that the supplement they buy from the clerk or online does not work.

Duh?! What do you expect?

You’ll save so much more money, frustration and time when you spend that time on a specialist, who can get your started on the right path right away.

First of all, “supplements” are not magic pills. They are just like the name says, “supplement”. 

Dictionary definition of “supplements”: something that completes or enhances something else when added to it.

Supplements is called supplement because it is supposed to supplement or fill the gap of a not-so-perfect diet. 

Let’s talk about what supplements are. They can be generally categorized into 3 types based on their purposes.

3 Functions of ADHD Supplements:

  1. To correct a nutrient deficiency
  2. To boost a function
  3. To correct a defective or weak biochemical pathway

1. The first category is mostly your essential vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that the human body needs. Things like vitamin A, B, C, D, E, and K, magnesium, zinc, iron, alpha lipoic acid, acetyl-L-carnitine, serotonin, melatonin, etc. These are what your body survives on.

2. The second category includes nutrients like zinc to boost immunity, alpha lipoic acid and acetyl-L-carnitine to boost mitochondria (cell’s powerhouse) function, especially for someone on a ketogenic diet or high-fat diet; or tyrosine to boost dopamine production.

3. The third category is where all the other herbal supplements and anything else belongs. The body does not have an essential need for these herbal supplements, but they function as medicines to treat something. MTHFR falls in this category. 

In fact, many medicines we use today come from plants. Pharmaceutical companies just take the active compound out of the plant, tweak a couple of molecules and make them super powerful, put a patent on and they can bank for 10 years on the “new drug”.

That’s why herbal supplements can be quite dangerous if not used properly.

The regular herbs and spices we use for cooking are safe because the amount we used in cooking is so little.

But when these are ground up and stuffed into a pill form or tincture, these can become powerful medicine in a concentrated form.

Here are 4 reasons why your Supplement of the Week does not work:

  1. Your diet is not dialed in. This is like taking an antidote while eating poison together every day. You can’t be eating processed junk food every day while taking a couple of supplements and expect miracles and transformation. 
  2. Wrong dose. The problem is usually “not enough.” It’s like exercise. We all know exercise is good for everyone. But if you only exercise once a year, don’t complain that exercise does not work for you. I call it the “Sprinkle Dilemma.” Like most multivitamin, there’s many vitamins and minerals in one pill, but it’s a just a sprinkle amount. A dose higher than the Daily Recommended Intake (DRI) is needed to correct deficiencies. 
  3. Wrong supplements. Again, there are many underlying causes of ADHD. If you don’t have a deficiency in vitamin D and/or iron, taking vitamin D or iron would do nothing. And in fact, taking too much vitamin D and/or iron can be harmful. Or if you take some random expensive supplements that claim to be for kids with ADHD. 
  4. Stop too soon. Many people don’t give the supplements enough to work. I see this all the time, especially with probiotics. Parents or adults stop probiotics at the first sign of stomach pain, diarrhea, or constipation. The truth is if the probiotics are causing something to happen, it is working. It’s just like remodeling your home, things have to get messy before the desired outcomes. 

The truth is treating ADHD naturally should be taken as seriously as starting ADHD medication, especially when your child has other medical conditions. Just because it’s natural does not mean it is completely safe. Like my sarcastic pharmacist intern always remind us, “Cyanide is natural too. Are you going to take it?”

It’s your child’s life and future. What is it worth to you?

Ok, there you have it…

I hope you find this information helpful. Let me know what you think and comment below. 

Remember ADHD does not doom your child to a life of under-achievement. You know your child is bright, full of potential, and deserves the best. In fact, many of the world’s greatest discoveries and inventions were made by people with ADHD.

I helped my crazy wild child who couldn’t read or write when she was little overcome her learning difficulties, and become a merit scholarship student majoring in premed at Loyola Chicago University.

So don’t give up, everything is possible. 

If you’re just starting out on this natural ADHD treatment journey and still in the research phase, check out my new book Eat to Focus.

Inside this book, you’ll learn why your ADHD child is always hungry, why he or she seems addicted to milk and bread, the reason why most ADHD treatments do not work, and the exact four strategies I’ve used for my daughter to help her calm down to focus and finally learn normally. 

This post may contain affiliate links.

***I include links in this post for your convenience to review the products that I recommend. There is no obligation for you to purchase any product. Some of these links may contain an affiliate link, and I may get a small commission from the sale to help offset the cost to keep this blog going. You know I only recommend products that I know works and trust. If you do make a purchase from one of these links, and I earn a small commission from it, I thank you for keeping this blog alive.***

The following two tabs change content below.

Anna

Clean Eating Officer (CEO) at Malama Wellness + Hypnotherapy
I'm Anna, a passionate dietitian and hypnotherapist dedicated to helping parents of kids with ADHD unlock the transformative potential of healthy eating and holistic approaches. With years of experience in pediatric nutrition and a focus on mind-body connection, I provide personalized guidance and practical tools to support positive behavioral changes and nurture your child's well-being.
I'm Anna, a passionate dietitian and hypnotherapist dedicated to helping parents of kids with ADHD unlock the transformative potential of healthy eating and holistic approaches. With years of experience in pediatric nutrition and a focus on mind-body connection, I provide personalized guidance and practical tools to support positive behavioral changes and nurture your child's well-being.